Earlier this month, Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood announced the Government’s final plans for “earned settlement”. Under the new model, most migrants will no longer qualify for indefinite leave to remain (ILR) after five years in the UK. The standard qualifying period will double to ten years, with shorter routes for the highest earners and some public service workers. The Home Office describes the change as a move away from automatic entitlement, with the right to settle earned through contribution and character.
The announcement confirms most of the proposals in the Government’s November 2025 consultation, with one significant change. The Government has dropped the proposal that lower-paid workers, including care workers, should wait 15 years before applying for settlement.
So, what do these changes mean for sectors that have relied heavily on migrant workforces, and how far can domestic training pipelines fill potential shortages?
The Current Immigration Landscape
Under “earned settlement”, how long a migrant waits before applying for ILR will depend on what they earn and the work they do. The highest earners (earning at least £125,141 a year) will be able to settle within three years, while those earning more than £50,271 and some public service workers, including doctors, nurses and teachers, will be able to settle after five years. For most other migrants, ten years becomes the default. The Home Office estimates more than 500,000 people will wait longer than five years.
Every applicant will also need to meet four non-negotiable conditions, regardless of when they arrived: a spotless criminal record, English at A-Level standard, no debt owed to the taxpayer, and a record of sustained National Insurance contributions. None of this is in force yet. The Home Secretary told the Commons the changes will be implemented over the course of 2027.
Earned settlement builds on earlier changes to the work routes. In July 2025 the Government raised the Skilled Worker skills threshold to RQF 6 (graduate level) and the general salary threshold from £38,700 to £41,700, while the threshold for most Health and Care Visa holders on national pay scales remains at £25,000. From December 2025, the Immigration Skills Charge also rose by 32%, to £1,320 per worker per year for medium and large sponsors, with the aim of encouraging employers to train local staff.
These measures have coincided with a sharp fall in net migration, to an estimated 171,000 in the year to December 2025, down from a record high of 944,000 in the year ending March 2023. The effects can be seen most clearly in adult social care.
Care Workers and Social Care
New entry clearance recruitment for care workers and senior care workers ended on 22 July 2025. Health and Care Worker visas issued to migrant workers in a Caring Personal Service occupation fell by over 99% (107,772 to 344) in YE June 2026 compared with YE December 2023.
With overseas recruitment largely stopped, the earned settlement decision mainly affects care workers already in the UK. Those who entered or switched into the route before the Immigration White Paper in May 2025 will keep the existing five-year path, provided they have met their visa conditions and earned at least £25,000 a year. Those who do not meet the requirements can apply for a further five-year visa, while care workers who joined after May 2025 will follow the standard ten-year pathway. Up to 300,000 foreign care workers will avoid the planned 15-year wait.
The Home Secretary has argued that without reform, about 350,000 low-skilled workers and their dependants would gain settlement and benefit access within five years. The Government also points to exploitation of migrant workers by employers in the sector. The fiscal case is disputed. The Home Office estimated the net lifetime fiscal cost of care workers expected to settle between 2026 and 2030, and their adult dependants, at £9.5 billion, and Shadow Home Secretary Chris Philp has claimed the ‘U-turn’ will cost the taxpayer £10 billion. Others note the figure estimates the lifetime cost of the cohort settling under current rules rather than the savings from delaying settlement, and the Home Secretary has acknowledged that savings will be lower than £10 billion.
The sector broadly welcomed the change but argues it does not go far enough. Unison said the route to settlement remains too demanding, while the Homecare Association argued in its consultation evidence, back in February 2026, that it is “unreasonable for the Government to penalise careworkers in immigration decisions for low pay that government policy itself creates.”
These debates are taking place while the domestic workforce is shrinking. Skills for Care’s latest data show the vacancy rate fell to 6.2% in 2025/26, but posts filled by people with British nationality fell by around 40,000 that year, and by 130,000 since 2020/21. The care sector is projected to need an additional 410,000 posts by 2040. With the overseas route now closed, it is unclear how far domestic recruitment can make up the difference.
Health and the NHS Workforce
Doctors and nurses will still be able to settle after five years, but international recruitment into the NHS has fallen sharply. Health and Care Worker visas issued to nursing professionals fell by 95% (22,858 to 1,125) between YE December 2023 and YE June 2026, and visas for medical practitioners fell by 42% in the latest year. This matters because 30% of nurses working in the NHS in England have a non-UK nationality, up from 15% in 2009, according to the Nuffield Trust.
The fall in nurse recruitment has several possible explanations. The Department of Health and Social Care has pointed to the end of the centrally supported international recruitment programme and changes in demand for international staff, while the Nursing and Midwifery Council has cited better earning potential elsewhere, visa changes and a push for domestic recruitment. NHS finances may also play a part, with the Royal College of Nursing finding that nurse numbers have consistently fallen when finances are particularly tight. These factors overlap, so the effect of visa policy is hard to isolate.
Health policy is also moving away from international recruitment. The 10 Year Health Plan (2025) aims to reduce international recruitment to less than 10% of new NHS starters by 2035, and the Medical Training (Prioritisation) Act (2026) prioritises UK graduates for foundation and specialty training. Both rely on the same assumption, that domestic training can grow fast enough to replace international recruitment.
Contributors to our Higher Education Commission’s latest inquiry, Trained for Tomorrow, said that contingency planning for a reduction in international recruitment was inadequate. The starting point is challenging. England has 3.2 doctors per 1,000 people, compared with an OECD EU average of 3.9, and nearly a third of nurses, midwives and health visitors are over 50.
Training more staff also depends on having enough people to teach them. According to the Royal College of Nursing, 75% of universities have had to reduce nursing staffing costs, a third of nurse lecturers are responsible for 80 or more students, and a quarter are considering leaving the profession. Trained for Tomorrow calls for a national strategy for healthcare educator capacity, including investment in early-career routes into education and a review of pay and recognition for educators.
Apprenticeships offer another route. The 10 Year Health Plan commits to 2,000 more nursing apprenticeships over three years, and the evidence on retention is encouraging. An evaluation of midwifery degree apprenticeships found attrition of between 0% and 4%, compared with 13% on the traditional route. However, from January 2026, Growth and Skills Levy funding for Level 7 apprenticeships has been restricted to those aged 21 and under. A mitigation fund keeps funding for five Level 7 healthcare apprenticeships, but only until 2029. Trained for Tomorrow recommends securing the fund beyond 2029 and extending it to all healthcare apprenticeships where Level 7 is a qualifying route.
The closure of the overseas care worker route and tighter work visa rules have already reduced international recruitment into health and social care, and earned settlement will change the terms on which those already here can stay. The 10 Year Health Plan (2025) and the Medical Training (Prioritisation) Act (2026) signal that further reductions are planned. Whether domestic training can grow fast enough to meet demand depends on investment in educators, stable funding for apprenticeships, and better regional workforce planning. To facilitate this growth, Trained for Tomorrow recommends integrated care boards lead jointly with universities, colleges, and regional skills bodies.
In December 2026, the All-Party Parliamentary Group for Skills, Careers and Employment (APGSCE) will host an event exploring how sector jobs plans aim to reduce reliance on migration in priority sectors, within and beyond health and social care, and how effective new pathways into these roles have been.
To find out more about our work, please contact Max Bishop (max.bishop@policyconnect.org.uk).